Nyaa archive 1508010
[Bunny-Apocalypse] Irina - The Vampire Cosmonaut (BDRip 1920x1080 x264 AAC-FLAC) [Dual-Audio] "Tsuki to Laika to Nosferatu"
Saved on 2022-07-07 11:45:40. This copy includes the description and comments available at capture.
Description
Video Source: ReinForce
Audio Source: Yameii ( English Dub AAC ), ReinForce ( Japanese FLAC )
Subtitle Source: Signs ( EMBER ), Dialogue ( EMBER )
Media Info: https://pastebin.com/pHNWMSzT
Ep10 v2
Comments 36
Thanks!
I appreciate the uploads but was just wondering why you switch from x264 to x265 and back again. Makes my head spin lol
UCUSS, ReinForce, LowPower-Raws ( x264 )
Moozzi2, Beatrice-Raws ( x265 10-bit )
IrizaRaws,ANK-Raws,Yousei-raws ( x264 10-bit )
Their quality is awesome so thats why they are used, have been downloading their encodes for so long and hard to compare ( depends on the release ).
The main reason ReinForce was used this time is because only he made the encode and did a great job as usual.
I'd rather stick with a Crunchyroll WEB-DL or even perhaps a Judas bitrate starved mini-encode than watch an encode from UCUSS, LowPower, Moozzi2, Iriza, or ANK. They're pretty garbage quality honestly and I've never met an encoder who disagrees with that statement.
Moozzi2 tends to meme filter (or use to? seems most of their more recent stuff is completely unfiltered) to the point that they massively wipe out all background details, one example shown before was the erasure of every star in the night sky in one show, etc... and they like to max sharpen the image to the point of halos everywhere, up the contrast and saturation so everything is orange and blown out.
Looking at who has encoded the BDs of this show though... I don't see any other options, so ReinForce was probably the "best" of those listed on Nyaa at this time.
ReinForce don't filter so their encodes are chock full of banding and everything else the source would have and because of their encode settings they sometimes lose too much detail. But they're generally regarded as a somewhat decent unfiltered encode when nothing better has shown up.
Why are you still not tagging subtitle tracks properly?
*appreciation

@Mabby not tagged properly? more info would help
@ChaoXide Judas quality is horrible on a 24 inch monitor or even a tablet, tried their releases but found EMBER to be much better, as for all the encoders listed, have watched most of the shows with a 65 inch TV and the details are amazing. you can say whatever you like about them but comparing the releases on a Screen will show the difference. How is comparing WEB-DL to BD even an argument, WEB-DL is nice a 42 inch TV, but above that you need a BD release. But it is hard to believe so here are some comparisons between BD and WEB.
Judas is shit, I agree... but the reason I included them was to emphasize how much more shit the others are. EMBER is also garbage and usually has reports of audio sync issues, mono audio (how does this even happen? lmao), lack of fonts and attachments, and low quality video. Easily another group to avoid if quality is goal.
Simple: a half decent WEB-DL is better than a shit BD encode.
This is completely nonsensical. Source doesn't have anything to do with what it'll look like blown up on bigger screens. Resolution does (and of course your players scaler solution).
In reality there are plenty of WEB-DL offerings that are superior to their BDMV counterparts these days for several shows. Even outside of anime... there are WEB-DLs of Disney shows that the WEB-DL is superior to the Blu-rays.
Being labeled Blu-ray doesn't actually mean it's automatically better than any of the WEB releases... which is why we make comparisons instead of just replacing willynilly. Some might say "but but the animation improvements"... but it's pretty common that shows don't always have animation improvements on BD and in some cases the "improvements" weren't really improvements.
At the end of the day, I wouldn't trust someone who defends such shitty encoders to actually make a judgement call on a comparison.
smh, here I was being honest and sincere and trying to be informative and helpful and yet you go off on a poor attempt to troll.
If you're gonna troll, try trolling better next time.
Expected better from someone still intentionally misnumbering demon slayer season 3, using worse audio, and shitty subtitles, despite being called out for it. =P
damn chill, you will lose some hair if you keep worrying about it. But I can help resolve this argument. UCUSS Mieruko-chan vs NekomimiTeikoku release. Make a small comparison please, I downloaded them both but deleted it after finding BD to be better, and it's actually season 2 not season 3 just because you like to name it according to your media server's preference doesn't mean it is ( I don't use any, good old SMB ). If you have season 3 please give me the leaked release
Episode 10 has misplaced subtitles, both tracks are signs as it is also the case in Ember's release. Ember has put a download link for episode 10 in their description: https://nyaa.si/view/1507596
thanks, will upload v2 for ep10 tomorrow.
sorry just read about the audio and subs part hehe, Funi audio is not better than CR audio ( if it is im sorry i dont notice it used marshall monitor ii anc to check ) not enough of a reason to switch audio just because funi has 256kbps, as for subs if you think the subs are better just because of 1 subtitle sign and episode 1 subtitle speed issue then you are simply ignorant going with the hate trend of anime chap.
https://slow.pics/c/gYg59R0I signs are clearer than normal subs especially for dub watchers, there is a saying.
All of your releases have the full english subtitles untagged so they show up as unknown language (und). A lot of people have their video player config setup to automatically default to specific tracks. Most releases use tagging to designate the honorifics track as enm and normal track as eng. Some groups sometimes tag signs as eng and full subtitles as jpn so it lines up with the eng & jpn audio tracks by default. Then there are groups that tag the full subtitles as eng and signs as mul or zxx. Even just eng for everything would be okay.
i.e. mpv.conf
I personally like enm/eng/zxx (or mul) for honorifics/full/signs but don't mind jpn/eng or eng/eng for full/signs. It doesn't matter whichever you prefer to use, as long as all muxed tracks are tagged. You are sourcing your subtitles from releases which generally are tagged properly but untagged in your release. Because of this, if you ever mux out the dubbed audio / signs track, the video would no longer use the remaining sub track by default when opened since it isn't tagged a language and isn't flagged default track (due to having had the signs default).
Use MKVToolNix if you are muxing releases together, or you may need to update your script to include tagging flags. Setting properties for flags and lang tags is as simple as clicking on the codec type inside the source container and re-muxing.
so can I use signs and song and english audio determined as eng, and japanese audio and dialogue determined as ja? ( or should dialogue be eng as well ), I keep dialogue as und because mpv keeps deciding 2nd track as default, i think will just add signs as 2nd track instead from now on, thanks.
MPV would only open the 2nd track by default if you had the first track flagged default track no and second track flagged default track yes. Alternatively if you had the forced display flagged yes for the 2nd track. If both subtitles exist, both are tagged eng, and both are tagged default yes, it should always use the first track. You could also just make sure only the first track is tagged default yes and the rest are no / aren't using forced display.
I don't mind whichever format you prefer to use for tagging, just as long as all tracks are tagged something appropriate. Muxing groups all have their own preference. If you wish to use ja/eng & ja/eng for audio and subs, that's fine by me. Just try to keep the muxing order consistent? :)
Signs track as ENG, Default, and Forced.
Full track as ENG, not Default, and not Forced.
Will work in mpv just fine. If you're wanting to play signs and yet getting full subs, then you've misconfigured your player.
alang=eng
slang=eng
subs-with-matching-audio=no
Will give you the forced ENG track. If you have alang=jpn it'd then give you the full subs track.
Not true.
subs-with-matching-audio=yesis default behavior and if you had jpn audio with both the signs and full subs tagged eng, it would not match the full subtitles with jpn audio if the signs track was defaulted first.Just retested this to confirm I was correct. Also spoke with an mpv developer about these settings and their intended behavior prior.
Only way you should be getting Signs track in this case is if the signs track isn't properly labeled as Forced.
The subs-with-matching-audio setting is basically saying: If audio language matches subtitle language should we play forced track (no) or full track (yes). If audio language doesn't match subtitle language then this setting should actually be ignored outright.
So if audio is JPN, then the subs-with-matching-audio setting only matters if slang is also JPN.
When testing just now, setting that to yes or no still gives me full subs if audio is Japanese and subtitles is ENG.
So if the signs track is properly tagged as Forced and both the signs and the full subs are marked as ENG then:
alang=jpn
slang=eng
subs-with-matching-audio=no
or even
alang=jpn
slang=eng
subs-with-matching-audio=yes
Should play Japanese audio and give you the non-forced ENG subtitles which would be the 2nd track aka full subs.
If you're getting the signs track, then I would have to say it's likely not properly tagged as Forced.
While
alang=eng
slang=eng
subs-with-matching-audio=no
Will play English audio and give you the forced ENG subtitles which would be the signs track.
and lastly:
alang=eng
slang=eng
subs-with-matching-audio=yes
Should play English audio and give you the Full subtitle track that is not Forced.
The problem is that very few release groups properly use the Forced flag when muxing, which of course breaks the ability to have automatic preferences work across the board as intended.
https://pastebin.com/ZuJUFpkH, if this labeling is ok please let me know, if not please edit the necessary changes on pastebin and send the link. This works fine with me.
@friendevil22
The order of the tracks doesn't matter. Full subs can be first and signs could be the 35th track or vice verse and preference settings will still work as long as language codes and forced flags are properly configured. The issue brought up above seems to be that you were labeling some full subs as UND which made it so preference settings couldn't work since they're setup to look for ENG tracks.
Years back I did the whole ZXX as signs thing because players didn't properly abide the Force flag setting in their preference setups (MPC needed config in advanced LAV settings to do so)... but players have since fixed this problem, came up with a solution, and made it pretty easy to setup a preference. So there isn't any reason to choose alternate language codes anymore in order to get preferences between signs or subs.
Because forced takes priority, making the setting irrelevant.
Most groups don't touch the forced display setting for this exact reason and only have a default track order with other tracks tagged a language. Some groups would want to tag the full subtitles as both listed first in the order, default, & forced rather than the signs, which would incorrectly cause this to play japanese audio and the signs track. That means the flag would only be "functional" if people relied on forced for signs only, which is bad.
The best is to ignore forced and just have a standard order with a default track and all tracks tagged in whichever format you prefer.
jp/eng + jpn/eng
jp/eng + eng/eng
jp/eng + eng/enm/mul
jp/eng + eng/enm/zxx
This and that muxing out english audio / signs track caused subtitles to not load whatsoever since it was not tagged default or any language.
Wrong. Forced is not a priority setting. Forced flag simply tells the player this track is intended to be played only with matching audio language.
So a Forced English subtitle track is intended to be played ONLY with English audio in the event the users doesn't want Full subs.
I know this confuses some folks because the name "Forced" implies something it is not. It doesn't "Force" the track to be played, it doesn't Prioritize the track. It simply is a flag to let the player know it's a Signs track.
Setting the Forced flag for Signs tracks is REQUIRED and the intended practice for preferences to work as intended. Any other use of the Forced flag is wrong.
Even the Blu-ray spec uses the Forced flag in order to display subtitles during non-English dialogue in movies... or for signs tracks on anime.
Netflix also uses it for the dozens of audio options to display proper signs tracks with each audio separately. If you take a look at some of the rips with the 30+ subtitle tracks, many of them are Forced signs tracks of the various language options. Because every language has a need for their own signs.
No, the best is to properly tag things as intended, with the correct language codes and proper use of the forced flag.
If people actually would do it right, everything works as intended.
https://gitlab.com/mbunkus/mkvtoolnix/-/wikis/Default-and-forced-flags-and-default-yes-no-in-the-GUI

AKA taking priority.
For general media that defaults to english and has translation required subtitles, yes. Forced is not something that makes sense for anime. No group should be using it. Just have a default order and lang tagging preference.
@ChaoXide you know the rules after losing an argument
lmao funny, but you tagged the wrong person. Mabby literally just proved me correct.
@Mabby
Seems you've completely misunderstood what that says as it's literally restating exactly what I've stated.
Wrong. The forced flag exists solely for signs type tracks.
The subs-with-matching-audio setting is saying: If audio language matches subtitle language should we play forced track (no) or full track (yes). If audio language doesn’t match subtitle language then this setting should actually be ignored outright.
So if audio is JPN, then the subs-with-matching-audio setting only matters if slang is also JPN.
So the signs track must be tagged as Forced to work properly with preference settings while still correctly labeling both subs as ENG.
If you're not using the forced flag, then the whole subs-with-matching-audio setting is useless since the whole reason it was created was to determine whether you want the forced signs track or the full subs.
Not properly tagging things breaks the ability to set preferences.
I'll see you on the flip side when groups ever start to use it and use it properly then. Until then, it's not something people are or (should) use for anime.
@friendevil22 Sorry for all the arguing. I just wanted you to start tagging the full subtitles properly in your releases. :)
ChaoXide is correct by the way.
Good thing the groups that matter all happen to have learned to do so then and have been doing so for the past 4 years or so.
Catar, LostYears, Arid, sam, Vodes, SCY, 0x539, MTBB, NH, Cry, WBDP, karios, Sola, Pizza, Foxtrot, GSK_kun, Lulu, Smoke, YURASUKA, Hark0n, MK, HaiveMind, UDF, Baws, Netaro, Dae, Spoony, EJK, -KS-, Datte13, Galator, DragsterPS, and dozens more I'm not going to spend all day naming.
In fact you'll be hard pressed to find a decent group that is providing signs tracks that don't use the Forced flag as intended these days.
Only group in recent memory I recall not properly using the Forced flag is Yellow-Flash.
Shoot even friendevil22 had started to properly use the Forced flag after others had commented asking him to.
For someone so adamant about doing things properly you sure are advocated to do things wrongly by disregarding the forced flag which is what allows preferences to work as intended on mpv, Plex, Kodi, and just about every other playback solution.
Insisting that people continue to do something wrong on purpose because you incorrectly feel like others aren't doing it right is a good way for things to never get better. It's much more productive to try to get everyone to do things correctly instead.
im blushing, deleting this torrent to present the proper tags and wont change them anymore.
Edit: nvm just gonna do it for v2 ep10 and will start next time :p
Then I hope those that don't and are releasing dual audio releases nowadays are called out for it. As I've come across numerous releases which had subtitles improperly displaying because of forced flag misuse. I generally lean towards single audio releases or muxing out unneeded tracks in dual releases, so forced is irrelevant regardless.
For groups that use to only release in JPN/ENG tagged full/signs subs, forced was irrelevant being set with a user lang config. Perhaps it was a different fansubbing era where they did things differently. But yes, I agree if all subtitles are tagged as english and only the signs track is properly flagged forced instead of the full one, this is ideal.
Sure, I agree with that. But mind you, I only cared to bring attention to the full subtitles being improperly tagged in friendevil22's release.
@ChaoXide considering he made a tantei mux that used IrizaRaws right after I released a filtered encode of it and other releases like Kakegurui XX where there exists a good encode already but he used nii-sama instead, id say he doesnt know or care at all about video quality.
If you see it, then call them out on it. I usually do if it's a user I feel would be willing to listen or simply new to the game and didn't know.
Hell I myself had to be convinced to actually use the forced flag as well back a good 5-6 years ago by Catar while fansubbing because I was also confused about what it was meant for and thought that it legitimately forced the subtitle track to be on, but that was wrong. We all learn as we go.
The worst that can happen if you bring it up is they refuse or try to fight about it. While it's possible they will be understanding and actually make changes. It's even more possible when multiple people bring it up rather than just one user.
Yeah, in typical fansub releases with only Japanese audio and English full subs there is never a reason to use the forced flag ever.
As for the labeling full subs as JPN despite being English subtitles or labeling signs as ZXX... this was all done to get around the fact that people didn't know what the forced flag was for and thus wasn't using it... as well as the fact that at the time most video players didn't take into account the forced flag correctly when determining what to automatically select based on the simple settings they had. It was only in the last couple years that mpv itself finally worked out the kinks in order for the solution to work. ZXX signs or JPN full subs were workaround methods of the time, but weren't ideal because they improperly label the language as something it's not... and now all of those releases are busted with the preference options we have today.
just don't care about people's opinions when I have tested other releases from so long ago, an example I haven't downloaded any of your torrents from so long ago because simply didn't like them.
Edit: take it however you want but it is what it is.
I do try as much as possible whenever I happen to catch a release improperly tagged. See: Reza's Shokugeki release. Or Vodes' HxH release (Simplistic's comment). Or the initial reasoning behind commenting here. However I don't particularly care about dual audio so my random QC only stretches so far. If all modern release groups are on board with properly using the forced flag, then I'm all for it. I've just come across a handful which aren't.
I meant more in terms of groups that released dual audio in a tagging format matching JPN/JPN (japanese + full) & ENG/ENG (english + signs). Forced wasn't relevant with a user config back then. And of course isn't relevant in single audio releases.
👍
I couldn't care less what you personally think of my releases, but video quality is objective and ive yet to see a single release from you that doesn't have objectively bad or worse than what already exists video quality
@Reza27 and again any opinion of yours or anyone's doesn't matter if differences have been checked. There you go ChaoXide downloaded one video file for comparing and it isn't just the ending, this was fun.