Nyaa archive 1453094
[MTBB] Zoku Owarimonogatari (BD 1080p)
Saved on 2022-02-14 21:55:17. This copy includes the description and comments available at capture.
Description
TL (dialogue/songs): Unbased
Everything else: motbob
There are alternate honorifics tracks in this release. Set your media player to play “enm” language tracks by default to automatically play honorifics tracks.
Please leave feedback in the comments, good or bad.
Please read this short playback guide if you want to know how to make the video and subtitles of this release look better.
Anyone wanting to do their own release is free to use any part of this torrent without permission or credit.
You should probably delete the old 720p release if you have it. The typesetting color was consistently way off due to a boneheaded mistake by me (experienced fansubbers might be able to guess what I did), and the encodes weren't great. They were very filesize-efficient, but they didn't look very good in high-motion scenes, and they used gradfun debanding (so there was some detail loss).
So let's take this opportunity to talk about the encodes for Monogatari.
Broadly speaking, there are three sets of great encodes that have come out for this series: Commie, Kawaiika-Raws, and mawen. But the quality of the first two varies significantly over the course of the series. For example, Commie's Owari 1080p encodes have noticeable detail loss. And Commie's Neko Black encodes generally beat Kawaiika due to more aggressive debanding.
I've done tests of most of the series at this point, and I've come to the following conclusion on which raws are best, based solely on filtering quality:
Bake-Nise: mawen (ties with Kawaiika/Beatrice, wins the tie due to filesize)
Neko Black-Otori: Commie (better debanding, no little resulting detail loss that I can see. The only advantage Kawaiika has is its sharper lineart due to rescale)
Oni-Koi: Kawaiika (wins by default, VCB is unusable due to crushed blacks)
Hana-Zoku: Kawaiika
For Hana, Kawaiika wins just because of the deshimmering they did in a few scenes. That's such a noticeable change that it dwarfs any other differences in the encode. For Tsuki and Kizu, Commie and Kawaiika are tied except for the sharper lineart in Kawaiika due to rescaling, which I personally prefer and I think most viewers do too. For Owari 1 and Zoku, Commie's and my encodes are unusable.
So Kawaiika is the best option for some shows, filtering-wise. Problem is, they're huge. Kawaiika used x265, crf 14.8 (equivalent of crf 13.8 in x264), qcomp 0.72, no cutree, aq 3:0.85. If you want transparency on every frame, those are great encoding options to use. But if you're not watching Monogatari by going frame-by-frame, they might be a little much.
I did reencodes of Kawaiika (crf 15.5, qcomp 0.70) and made screenshot comparisons. Kawaiika ended up being 1.8-2.5x the size of the reencodes. You can judge for yourself whether that extra filesize is worth it, but for me, it's not even close. Hell, in the frame comparison linked above, the banding in the shot (in the middle of the face) somehow looks better in the reencode!
As a result of my tests, I'm going to be releasing Kizu, Hana, Tsuki, Owari1, and Zoku on Kawaiika reencodes, along with Koi/Oni unless there are Commie encodes sitting on an FTP server somewhere. If you're dissatisfied with the artifacts caused by a freaking crf 15.5, qcomp 0.70 encode, then don't worry, I'm sure someone will remux my subs to Kawaiika for you. Though, for the people who're remuxing the entire series onto Kawaiika: please do some research. There may be better alternatives for pre-Hana arcs.
Comments 25
I love how detailed this description is, and thanks for the release. I've been waiting to download this as always with all of the monogatari seasons.
wtf most of the commie encodes suck are are low/no effort. and like you mentioned, none are descaled since i didn't know how to do it at the time. i could make way better encodes now if i tried, especially since i still have the scripts for the stuff i scenefiltered so i can just copy over the frame ranges but do better filtering on them.
Looking forward to it.
reencodes based confirmed
probably because of HEVCs smoothing for a second time
but re-encodes are bad, so you can't use them ever, no matter how good they look
I am going to download everything from you and then kawaiika remuxes with your subs if they are available. Based researchcel Bobby.
Not in this case, since I used x264
o
>264 to 265 to x264 re-encode. Quite the sin you've commited eh?
Lmao
Time to switch to potplayer
Gracias as always
motbased
Where the heck is my weekly dose of Mushoku?
Shouldn’t you mark the release as red then?
As always thanks for your work on gatari
Not that the red rules are enforced or consistent on this website, but on old nyaa, the "Reencode of original release" rule applied to people making handbrake .mp4 encodes and such, not to releases where any reencoding whatsoever happened.
Thanks for the service motbob, now please walk me home gently!
@motbob well this is new nyaa, and so that means anything but audio is considered re-encode. This is consistently self-policed here.
Eh? They're pretty standard size for decent releases. All the episodes are ~1.5gb, mostly less.
Oh boi.
Instances where I'm super happy remuxers exist lol.
Thanks for the subs though :)
No comments on the image comparisons, I see. Yep, that's about right. Leechers care more about words and numbers than how something actually looks
'Course, you could end up looking at the comparisons and think, "these reencodes look like shit." And that'd be your right. But your comment should be exactly that, no more, no less. When the picture evidence is right in front of you, that's what should be the only focus.
No idea why you're getting upset man.
Why would I comment on video when you already acknowledged that the re-encode is inferior and has more artifacts.
Which is only more evident by just one look at the comps you have linked.
Kawaiika:
Your re-encode:
Also its not like I'm commenting on something that is totally out of topic or anything, you said Kawaiika is huge to which I actually went and checked the file sizes for all the seasons and its normal(~1.5gb per ep like I said).
the human eye can't spot quantization errors and faint lines anyway :^)
This show compresses well—lots of static shots. To test whether an encode is big or small due to the source or due to the encoding settings, you can't just look at filesizes, you need to do an alternate encode. More to the point, saying an encode is huge or bloated is a matter of settings or comparative filesize, not absolute filesize. I would never criticize Raws-Majj Mushoku for being bloated despite those encodes being 2.5GB/ep.
I mean, you can definitely spot them if you blow them up to 4x or whatever.
@motbob
Don't bother trying to defend "re-encodes of re-encodes", you'll never win against the people who make the complaints. Though, if you're not an elitist, they're just fine with the right encoding settings. (better than most web-dls anyway.) Though obviously, if BDMVs are available, it's a relatively dumb thing to do.
The only question is how the re-encodes deal with dynamic scenes. Since there is no tool to compare them online, I generally believe the bigger encode made by a competent encoder will look better than your attempt at reducing the filesize.
Truth to be told, I watch your releases on a shitty MacBook Air, there was a time where I cared way too much about this stuff, now I just don't, so in my case your encodes are way more than fine. Still, for archival reasons, I'll download the remixes.
Pixel peeping the screenshots is basically irrelevant because it's not a real-life scenario. Perhaps with some 4k monitor it could be different though, I never checked.
No! Stop… The truth… It's hurting!!!!!!!!!!
*appreciation