Nyaa archive 1267130

[JySzE] Naruto [R2J] [VFR] [Dual Audio] [Complete] [Extras]

Saved on 2020-11-08 01:35:34. This copy includes the description and comments available at capture.

Description


Thumbnails


I want to start off by thanking the people who made this release possible:

Enigmo: Thank you for the R2J Naruto Box Sets ( 1 - 135 ).
Arian: Thank you for the R2J Naruto Stage DVDs ( 136 - 220 ).
Scoped: Thank you for doing all of the subtitles and helping me QC video for the last 10 months.
Black Mist: Thank you for helping me QC video for the past 10 months.
Ergiman: Thank you for Syncing all of the English dub and for fixing some of the JP audio.
Romao: Thank you with encoding comparisons & help determining correct PAR.
Nemu: Thank you for helping translating some of the JP episode titles.
InoBestGirl: Thank you for making the banner and sneak peek footer.


Source: R2J Naruto DVDs
Video: CRF13 *¹ H264 8Bit *² @ 528p *³ VFR *⁴ [Mediainfo]
Japanese DVD Audio: FLAC *⁵
English DVD Audio: FLAC *⁵
Subtitles: English ASS (Sign & Songs + Full English Subtitles)

Best played on MPV or similar!


Filtering Done listed in no particular order:

Derainbowing

IVTC

Dot Crawl Removal

Combing Residual Removal

Chroma Bleed reduction

Cropping

Resizing

Dehaloing

Chroma Noise removal

Banding Reduction


Now comes to why :


*¹ : "WHY SO BIG? BLOAT!"

Yeah yeah I hear you, I started this release initially for my own viewing and was going to losslessly export it for the quality whore that I am. But then slowly others started helping me and they wanted me to share it with them. Not everyone who helped could download huge lossless 6GB+ files (even tho they wanted to), so I made a compromise of what kind of compression I could accept. Remember I never had in mind to share this at first and this release was made for me in mind I did not tailor this to nyaa in any way shape or form. Due to the time I spent with this project I did not feel like spending more money, time and effort encoding it twice for nyaa, I'd like to thank Romao for convincing me not to cave in and encode this at a smaller size just for nyaa and stay to the true spirit that started this project.


*² : "Why not 10bit!!!!"

This is an easy answer, Time and Money. Encoding this took well over a week of uninterrupted encoding and used a ton of power and time out of my life, encoding at 8Bit was much faster and I already had the dithering where I wanted and didn't want that to change.


*³ : "Why 528p!?"

What is PAR , Naruto has a PAR of 10:11.

Thumbnail*3/4=528

The resolution of NTSC DVD is 720x480 with 8:9 PAR. But this PAR does not represent what the original picture is meant to be. The correct PAR is 10:11 when displaying the video digitally rather than using CRTs which has overscan. If not manually resized, most players will display NTSC footage at 720x540, where the 540 pixel height is just 480 * 9/8.
Doing the same with the correct PAR, we get 480*11/10 = 528. To get 4:3 footage, the width is cropped to 704 to remove the black bars that are not visible due to CRT overscan.


*⁴ : "VFR?"

Yes Naruto is variable frame rate, all panning shots go well above 23.976 and all openings and endings are around 23 fps ~ 29.976 fps and change rapidly. The best example I could use is checking out NCOP4 of my release which is VFR. Then comparing with a 23.976 release, that shit is seizure inducing at 23.976. That is the best and quickest example I can give you of why naruto is VFR.


*⁵ : "FLAC? More Bloat?"

JP Audio: The PCM audio naruto comes with is roughly 260MB - 290MB each, Encoding to FLAC cuts them to around 40 - 50% of their original size without any loss in quality. I see no reason to reduce this further.

ENG Audio: The R1US Naruto DVD's come with ac3 audio, now you must be wondering why we decided to encode it to FLAC, its rather simple. AC3 is a lossy audio format and encoding a lossy format to another lossy format will result in quality loss. But a lossy source to a lossless format will result in the same quality as the source even with sync adjustments done to it.


Screenshots

Raw VS Filtered


Please report any and all sub issues to @Scoped#9782 via DM on discord with the episode number and timecode ready.

Fixed NCOP audio for 2,3 and 4 and NCED audio for 2,3,4 and 5 found here


Next up! Shippuuden!

Shippuden


Comments 130

The chad JySzE blesses us with a godly Naruto release sent from the heavens. May Allah assist you in your Shippuden endeavors Habibi. ? <--- Halal goat btw

Then we all should thank Romao for convincing you to keep the quality at it's best, orginal naruto has always suffered from bad releases and unsatisfying encodes, I think we deserve one in this level even if it make the size big.

Big thank you Jysze and the rest of the team.

@rozee "ENG Audio: The R1US Naruto DVD’s come with ac3 audio, now you must be wondering why we decided to encode it to FLAC, its rather simple. AC3 is a lossy audio format and encoding a lossy format to another lossy format will result in quality loss. But a lossy source to a lossless format will result in the same quality as the source even with sync adjustments done to it."

That sums it up pretty nicely.

@rozee well so if the point is keeping the original quality... how is it pointless? like you care about those, I don't know, 19GB (~90MB extra per episode) in a 300GB+ release that is explicitly quality focused and wants to keep everything intact as much as possible lol

@rozee
dawg you're legit retarded.
What's so hard to understand about encoding to flac to not lose quality? Reencoding to AC3 is legit the worst thing you can do especially when it's AC3 192kbps :kek:.

Looks like a great release all in all. Nice.

I tried getting into watching Naruto, but it wasn't for me. I do love the score and UbiSoft's Naruto Xbox 360 games (2.5D traditional fighter with TV soundtrack), though.

What’s so hard to understand about encoding to flac to not lose quality? Reencoding to AC3 is legit the worst thing you can do especially when it’s AC3 192kbps :kek:.

just remux the audio untouched, obviously.

@notaretard
I am probably falling for some kind of bait right now, but whatever. Please just keep the dumb comments out of this torrent. Jy worked REALLY hard on this project and doesn't deserve a shit storm of a comment section. I have seen comment sections on this website literally ruin entire torrents because people can't do any proper research on encoding before blasting their non sense take when people are offering what is basically free illegal content so you don't need to pay hundreds to watch your favorite shows. If you want 50 mb blocky compressed x265 encodes this isn't the torrent for you. At that point just watch it online.

Great thanks i have never watch naruto until now ...Will be à way to watch it, finally people start to care about qualité,. If someone want to do bleach like that it Will be à dream

Geez, now I have the dilemma of choosing this version or the one that Darkfire68 is doing... I really need to replace the Animax """""HD""""" Remaster.

The only drawback with this release is the AC3 to FLAC conversion. I mean, the 50% size that you reduced from the JP audio, now you are undoing it with the encode to FLAC in the ENG track.

Anyways, thanks for the HUGE effort with this project!

@Toppoer Yes the craziest.

@Nebula , @BJX, @iKaos, @dbz152, @bkarkai, @rnkz, @jillvalentine, @nemu, @Impakt, @RMgx, @Venny, @Chintu, @darkfire68, @DBM, @------, @jackiechun, @ScreenRant, @Archer0034

You are most welcome, Thank you all for the kind words to me and the team.

@herkz The audio needed cuts to get it to sync to the Japanese footage, if we could of used the untouched ac3 that is exactly what we would have done, Either way the audio needed to be encoded after the sync. Storage is cheap nowadays so I don't mind.

Also big shout out to user "Skoll" for noticing a odd JP audio issue with the NCOP 2, 3 and 4.

Fixed audio for it can be found here:

NCOP2
NCOP3
NCOP4

Guys,to those of you who are sceptic about this,i can assure you that this is the best/definitive release for naruto,visually and audio wise.We worked hard for this release to happen,by dedicating hours of our lives.I chose the audio to be lossless for the reason that JySzE mentioned.The audio took me 2 months to sync and to quality check,if you want smaller file size go download a shitty encode of naruto that has blocking,the wrong framerate and shitty audio,this torrent is for those who want quality.

P.S:i recommend you to watch this on your tv

Thank u guys!, @rozee Most programs like Audition, Premiere etc make you re-encode the audio when syncing which cost quality lost. By selecting the output to FLAC there is no quality lost at all at the cost of larger file size.

make you re-encode the audio when syncing which cost quality lost. By selecting the output to FLAC

you mean re-encodes the audio when exporting because re-encoding during sync, if it is even possible, would mean quality is already lost.

@sameer no. when you edit the audio its the same quality as the source, and exporting it lossless means it will be the same quality as the source only with the cuts needed to make it synced.

he said re-encodes the audio when syncing. do you agree with that? because that does mean you are already losing quality. exporting that as lossless won't give you lossless which is the same as source. moreover how you did those cuts is also another thing to consider before saying no quality loss.

nothing against your work. there are people who appreciate what you have done. i was just curious. there was one more thing that I had earlier asked because the description piqued my interest.

No he does not re-encode while syncing, It is edited in audacity directly from the source and then exported as FLAC.

This is the last I will respond to comments about the audio.

Take it or leave it.

I guess there needs to be an even clearer FAQ:

  • The English audio does not sync to the JP video with simple time-shifts; there are several cuts and shifts that need to be done. As a result, you cannot just make these changes losslessly. To prevent as much quality loss as possible, they exported the audio to another lossless format - in this case, FLAC. Would exporting to AC3 or another more size-conscious format have produced almost imperceptible results? Oh, absolutely, but I suppose much like the video, JySzE isn't particularly concerned with that, and simply wants the highest quality results.

  • This release vs DarkFire. Look, df68 is great guy and he's released some solid stuff over the years, so I say this from purely an analytical POV, and not an attack on his work. This release significantly trounces his to the point that I'm surprised there are claims otherwise. For one, you can find plenty of residual rainbowing throughout his release, the line darkening is far too extreme, and textural detail in things like backgrounds and CG elements are largely scrubbed away. Most critically, the release doesn't take into account the show's variable frame rate - OPs, EDs, pans, CG elements - they will all be significantly less smooth than what's found in this release. If you care about animation timing, this is especially important.

This is far and away the best Naruto has looked and will ever look until a miracle occurs and something better is released in an official capacity. If a competent encoder wants to come along and create a size-conscious, virtually transparent release, then by all means, please do! ~340GB is no small ask for the average person, but it is what it is.

Not a fan of Naruto, but this must’ve taken years of hard work and dedication. Respect. ? For all those complainers out there arguing over the audio, that’s quite useless considering all the work this group has done. Using CRF-13 took ages to encode all those videos. Keep up the godlike work. This is very rare, and you can't find it anywhere else.

the only way to keep an audio lossless when it don't auto sync with a simple delay is to export as flac cause it's the only way to get no loss, he didn't altered anything, if you can't understand something as simple as that then you'll not notice why this release is highly superior in everything with others release
people that focus on screenshot comparison should look in motion, you'll understand in motion in everyscrolling why (or you have shit in your eyes)
after if it's too big for you, just leave it and keep usual trash release on the web

-___-: This is a great upload indeed as I mentioned before. But please: "line darkening is far too extreme, and textural detail in things like backgrounds and CG elements are largely scrubbed away." I downloaded one episode, and checked the first scene: https://slow.pics/c/K8S8GuEd and after some time here: https://slow.pics/c/9rhHwXBF It is clear yes that I dropped VFR because for me it was pointless. This show's sources are not that great so I think it doesnt deserved it.

@JySzE
Big thanks to you and everyone who worked on this monstrous release. Making those shitty, artifact-riddled DVDs watchable is no easy task for sure. I greatly appreciate all the work that has gone into this.

@JySzE Dude can't thank you enough for this torrent. Really appreciate your effort.
Btw @df68 I love your encodes but the evidence you uploaded is purely fake or may be a mistake on your part but the one I got from this torrent doesn't look like that.

@JySzE Is the framerate fluctuation in shippuuden the reason CR sources have problems with panning shots in some episodes. itunes doesnt seem to have this problem. they are very jerky. cant seem to find a good answer to this. if u do with shippuuden what u have done with this that would be amazing. cant wait.

Nice and elegant project. Thank you very much to all involved.
You can clarify what DVD video source they used for episodes 136-148.

Enigmo: Thank you for the R2J Naruto Box Sets ( 1 - 135 ).
Arian: Thank you for the R2J Naruto Stage DVDs ( 149 - 220 ).

@-___- Thank you for helping me explain, was pretty sleep deprived when dropping this.


@Ingenioussubs Thank you for the kind words, Yeah you are 100% right, compression is a theme here at nyaa and with my releases it will never come to that. This is actually still smaller than the R2J remux even with dual audio so I consider it a absolute win. Im glad you agree.


@DBM much love friend.


@ThePi7on Hey dude! you been waiting a while huh, Sorry about that. Hope it was worth the wait thanks for the kind words. :)


@Tanteiouji Thanks I couldn't have done it without my team, they deserve all the love.


Oh my bad @Gotenusu that was a typo I appreciate you making me aware of that issue.

I will fix that now, episode 1 - 148 are the R2J Naruto Box Sets.


@revans68

Yes that is exactly why the panning shots in shippuden look like that, especially episode 1 as a great example. You can see what its really meant to look like with SOFCJ-RAW's 1 - 53 release which is VFR and done very well. If I had to choose a way to watch 1 - 53 for the time being it would be their release.


also @everyone be sure to check the desc for fixed audio for the NCED's and NCOP's the DVD i downloaded had damaged audio and only a few were messed up in the process credits to user "Skoll" for finding them.


Also for all you fellow dub fans, if you want the eng audio and sign subs to play by default throw this in the bat file and drop it in the main folder where the main videos are and run it, it will edit the mkv files without remaking them. Just be sure to have mkvtoolnix installed!

    for %%a in (*.mkv) do (
            echo %%~na
    "C:\Program Files\MKVToolNix\mkvpropedit" "%%~na.mkv" --edit track:a1 --set flag-default=1 --edit track:a2 --set flag-default=0 --edit track:s1 --set flag-default=1 --edit track:s2 --set flag-default=0 
    )
pause

@JySzE but the R2J Naruto Box Sets ends in episode 135.

From episode 136-220 onwards they are called "NARUTO Stages" which are individual DVDs.

Your torrent information does not specify where episodes 136-148 come from.

@Gotenkusu Just checked the R2J Naruto Box Set, Box 3 DVD 14 which is the last DVD and it does indeed end on 135.

I checked the Naruto Stage DVD "Naruto 4th Stage 2006 - Vol. 01" and that actually starts on ep 132 which shares identical footage to the Box Set, But I still used the footage for 132 - 135 from the Box Set and 136 - 220 from Stage Singles.

Here is an image of the DVD's Menu from the Naruto 4th Stage 2006 Vol.1 DVD:

screen

Had nemu translate it and he confirmed its ep 132, and I also confirmed the footage to match ep 132.

So it's:

Enigmo: Thank you for the R2J Naruto Box Sets ( 1 - 135 ).
Arian: Thank you for the R2J Naruto Stage DVDs ( 136 - 220 ).

I had remuxed these back in August 2019 so I had forgotten. Thanks for helping me clarify the release further.

Amazing release. Thanks so much for your work and effort! Looking forward to Shippuden release from you and your team. And one more thing, viewing your last comment, do you have the DVD menus or the DVD scans? If that's the case, would you consider sharing them? Here in Nyaa I haven't found any of those.

Are the subtitles based on a previous fansub release or are they new? Thank you for this release! Cheers.

I thought that this release will replace all the other releases, but sadly it's not, when comparing with r2dvd there are some color variation, not gonna lie, it is annoying at some parts.
I appreatiate that jysze paid a big attention to a lot of details that other encoder failed at, like the cgi scenes and vfr. But even with all this, this is still not a definitive release.

@Room
It's definitive in the sense that no other fucker has an encode that's better than it. That's how "definitive" releases work.
There is some colour variation due to the extreme amounts of rainbowing the source has. It is legitimately impossible to remove it all without influencing other colours with JySzE going through a huge amount of effort into making sure it influenced other "innocent" colours as little as possible but it's impossible to do so. Please recognise your sheer stupidy and refrain from commenting.
alt text

@itachi09847 Animax suffers from large chroma bleeding, dot crawl, color issues making everything look like pastel colors, and still has rainbowing. Your shot of mine is also upscaled to 4k for some odd reason.

The animax remaster was also done with much better sources than the R2JDVDs, So its line detail in SOME few parts will look better but then we end up with something like this alot from animax:
animax

@room
Id love to see what you are talking about but I probably already know, When removing rainbowing, chroma will always be slightly effected in some way or form. Just like the animax remasters looking creamy and pastel looking, but even they fail at removing the rainbowing. Id much rather have no rainbowing and slight chroma changes than sit around looking at this all day:
rainbowing

@-----
There is a difference in the aspect ratio in this compersion, can't fix it right now, couldn't correct it right now, but I think this show what I am talking about
https://slow.pics/c/xw4rQwOo
Check the backgrounds in the pic 1,2 and 4, it seems getting darker, in 3 check the face. It gives a kind of pale look to the images.

@Room, What episode is that + time code because my R2J DVDs dont look THAT bad or that bright at all.

Also that dvd whatever it really is looks horrible.

when comparing with r2dvd there are some color variation, not gonna lie, it is annoying at some parts.

Are these the R2 UK DVDs?, Because if your trying to say UK got it right and Japan got it wrong that's just wrong.

@jysze
It is episode 30 for the first 3, at the begining when sasuke attack, ep 71 for 4. I am talking from my phone at work so I cant give the exact time code right know.
In pic 3 there is also some kind of grey color shifted at his face.
Also it is r2j not uk

@room https://slow.pics/c/dBXia03I

Whatever you got is not R2J

Also that change in his face is due to rainbow removal, and only affects really far away shots. No filtering will be perfect that goes for any one who releases naruto. Including animax themselves a major company.

Also why does your screenshot differ so much from the actual encode? Seems to be a trend here.

https://slow.pics/c/m2mlP6WT

The screenshots is taken by mpc hc.
The source I used is the 3 box sets r2j, which is the same as mentioned in the describion box and in the comments.

@Room
Boss please stop talking. You clearly have something fucked up on your end. Don't come to this release bashing it when you are incapable of figuring your shit out :AkaShrug:.

Source I used is 3 box sets r2j

it clearly isn't tho or you have something fucked up with your media-player. Idk what you're using but I've confirmed that your screenshots are not representative of either the UK or Japanese DVD official releases. You have scrubbed details in your pic.Please check your media-player and shut the fuck up.

UK-DVD
alt text

JP-DVD
alt text

Your screenshot (resized)
alt text

Look at the bottom right below Sasuke. Hell you also have default-looking deinterlacing on as well as less footage from both DVDs. I believe you might have some sorta bizarre R2 DVD set downloaded or something similar downloaded.

The audio needed cuts to get it to sync to the Japanese footage, if we could of used the untouched ac3 that is exactly what we would have done, Either way the audio needed to be encoded after the sync.

you still don't need to re-encode the audio when doing that unless it's seriously fucked. just use tools like this or this, depending on whether you use avisynth or vapoursynth.

The English audio does not sync to the JP video with simple time-shifts; there are several cuts and shifts that need to be done. As a result, you cannot just make these changes losslessly. To prevent as much quality loss as possible, they exported the audio to another lossless format - in this case, FLAC.

no, this isn't true, though lots of people believe it for some reason. the only way that would be necessary is if for example one of the audios had to be sped up or slowed down to match, but i doubt that's the case here. in 99% of cases you can use the tools i linked above to easily sync lossy audio without re-encoding it. i have literally done it hundreds of times.

the only way to keep an audio lossless when it don’t auto sync with a simple delay is to export as flac cause it’s the only way to get no loss, he didn’t altered anything, if you can’t understand something as simple as that then you’ll not notice why this release is highly superior in everything with others release

incorrect. mkvmerge can losslessly cut and combine lossy audio at arbitrary points. you can easily automate it with the tools i linked above.

@JySzE i know that animax has a lot of rainbows and other stuff but i mean the overall quality is really better than your release but i don,t know how they achieved this level and what the source was. by the way there are a program called Topaz AI upscale it is just doing a really great job you can see some results here https://imgur.com/a/Kwd32wI

@itachi09847
The overall quality isn't better than his release. There isn't a single frame in his release that looks like this steaming hot dogshit. It's consistently great.
alt text

@Tgminer, @asc3nsi0n, @animewatchyou, @SymbtcnThry, @Rikudou

Thank you and you are welcome.

@herkz

Cool first link, I didn't personally sync it, but the way he did it is just fine and the syncer did it with what he's more akin to so free service I'm not about to go complaining since still lossless, feel free to continue.

@itachi09847

nice meme.

As someone who only read the manga, the best compliment I can give you guys is saying that this release has motivated me to actually watch Naruto.

Thank you for this amazing release!

@jillvalentine
i said i know it has a lot of issues like frame problems, motion, rainbows etc...! can't you just differentiate between these different things ??? the other thing is that you comparing between cropped and non-cropped versions which is not fair just try to compare between openings and endings
for example try to focus on the areas that i marked on the tow pictures and tell me which one have more details please : https://imgur.com/a/9iRvsTx

@SoulBurner, @Bleachway

You are welcome!

@itachi09847

Go watch animax then, You are screaming at the wind. Get me the composite masters if you want me to make my release better.

JySzE the problem is that animax is cropped version which is very annoying and deal breaker for me so i want to ask you if the animax version wasn't cropped, do you think you will use it as a source for your release or do you think R2J dvd is better ??

There will be a subtitle patch for v2 subs uploaded some time in the future. Any and all errors should be reported in order to make v2 subs easier to make.

Became a fan after your Dragon Box encodes. I'm not into Naruto myself but I appreciate what you've done. I've recommended this release to all of my friends who like Naruto and it's currently being saved on my shared virtual drive. Thank you all for your service!

Thank you so much! I've been trying to save most of the openings, and I'm so happy I found yours. The encoding is beautiful, thank you for the audio fixes. I am very eager for Shippuden, good luck and don't stress

This is a very impressive release and I especially appreciate stylized subtitles with the opening that you included.
Most Naruto releases I found had very poor subtitles (in terms of style, not script)
Can't wait for your future releases :)

Thats why i like the fans of big 3 thank you very much and i have one question you can reply if you want to. is it possible to do it at higher resulotion and higher bitrate i just wonder maybe someday i learn how to do this kind of stuff and make my own team to make the better version??? thank you again if you reply.

@DBM Hey actually there is a bleach release like that but no one is seeding it Bleach (S01-05) [01-109][US-BDRip][Dual Audio][1080p 8-Bit] its name at ibit torrent site

Thanks for this, love this encoding. Is it possible to get a patch to change English Audio and Signs subs to the default, also change the name [Ergiman] to English? Or does anyone have a video link to show me how to create one with MKVToolNix?

211411142314 ... use https://mkvtoolnix.download/doc/mkvpropedit.html
Quick "bat file" example:
for %%f in (*.mkv) do (
echo %%~nf
"C:\Program Files\MKVToolNix\mkvpropedit" --delete title --edit track:v1 --set language=jpn --set flag-default=1 --delete name --edit track:a1 --set language=eng --set flag-default=1 --set name=Stereo --edit track:a2 --set language=jpn --set flag-default=0 --set name=Stereo --edit track:s1 --set language=eng --set flag-default=1 --set name=Sign/Song --edit track:s2 --set language=eng --set flag-default=0 --set name="Full English" "%%~nf.mkv"
)
Pause

I do this all the time to default audio/subtitle preferences...run batch file inside file folder containing videos to be changed

Both subtitle tracks are the same "full english with signs/song combined" NOT just "signs/songs" and "english" separate :(

@JySzE

This is just fantastic. I'd never dream of such a find as this. Truly, thank you so very much for this.

Tragic story, I did once own every first print edition of all the Naruto Shippuden Japanese DVD's for the benefits.
Did make a backup copy of all, but one of the external HDD containing all the discs from season 10 to the last disappeared.
I only now still have season 1 to 9. Sold the DVD collection, but the blood, sweat and tears of getting them all and the time and money invested to end up losing the backup of over half of the series was a serious blow, enough to make me depressed for some time.

For those who might be interested, I did scan all the box sets, cover arts, cds, and the benefit contents for those who want it.
I know these scans don't exist anywhere on the net, hehe. (The booklets were not scanned though as it was not possible without ruining them)

On another note, I pulled the trigger and bought one of the German blu-rays (Staffel 24 - Episode 470-479) to inspect the quality.
Of course these are the later episodes that were natively in HD, but I can say the quality is by far the best one can get now.
These BD's are not cheap though, each season ranging from 35-69 euros each, and I can't afford it now to buy them all.
Interestingly enough, no one is talking about these BD's, which I find odd as they are official releases.

I'm willing to share the BDMV here, in hope that if someone else here own some of the German BD's or have them all might upload them here too for us others to download.

I was actually wondering if you @JySzE would want this?

Naturally, I myself would want all the BDMV's and make my own encodes. I'm currently working on a test upscale of a BEASTARS episode adding HDR color grading, which I plan to share here to see if it picks up any interest.

@brilliantscientist

Thank you


@D4V

started watching and saw the chapters where numbered, so instead of bitching about it I renamed the chapters. Here they are in case anyone else likes them like that. https://mega.nz/folder/QzRTjaqI#H9RKGsFzSmthy4bldjnBbg
@JySzE If they weren’t named because no one was willing to rename them I can do it for your Shippuuden release if that’s cool?

I appreciate that, they werent renamed cause I didnt even think about it tbh. Thanks for the named chapters with the v2 il be sure to add them and credit you.

If you want to do shippuden im fine with that, post your discord and I will add you.


@DonCanjas

Thank you


@StevenIsSoHot

Thank you


@OCG

Thank you v2 with fixed subs are coming up eventually.


@Clemsi

You are welcome, shippuden soon.


@CatLady

Thank you and yes I agree thanks again D4C for the named chapters.


@211411142314

I already posted how to here, the english audio is already tagged as English so Idk why you'd need to put english again:

https://nyaa.si/view/1267130#com-59


@Clemsi

no sorry, good luck.


@YAZZ

Appreciate the kind words, yes for my shippuden release I will be using some of the German BD's but not for the releases entirety because of the encoding issues with the early HD eps. I already have all the Shippuden German BD's I am going to be using but I appreciate you trying to actively show your support.

@JySzE That is incredible! I'm super curious as to the quality on the rest of the seasons. As for the early seasons, I remember the rumors on those BD's was that they looked worse than the DVD quality, but that was also during a time when these German BD's were on their first releases. Would it be possible to somehow be able to download the BDMV's? Don't really expect anything nor want to ask for anything much as I understand it'd be a huge upload/download. Either way, I'm more than happy to support in any way I can. These encodes are quite clean, and honestly I'm quite sure your Shippuden encodes will we as great, though I always go for the DVD ISO or BDMV's whenever possible.

All in all, a tremendous thank you.

@YAZZ I'm sorry for your data loss. maybe it can help you to recover the data from that external HDD. How can I contact you?

You can share here all the box sets, cover arts, cds, and the benefit contents?

I see... Because I want to use your release to do a recut based on the manga, but I don't know if I should wait a V2 or not.
I can wait, but if you are not going to do a V2, that means I can start my project right now.

If you do a V2, the changes will be minor or major ?

@Cemsi its gonna be a worthy upgrade and good luck trying to cut the VFR footage while retaining the timecodes.

I compared this Naruto release with the df68 version. I definitely saw loss of details and extreme smoothing done on this release. The screen shots df68 are real and true. I noticed there is a lot of ego and arrogant people who are NOT being objective. They refuse to see and accept anyone else doing the encode being better in other aspect. I watched both releases' first five episodes. The df68 version is more sharp and easy to watch. This version is just too smoothed out and there is a loss of details.

There is too much subjective analysis happening with those saying otherwise.
If you are objective, this version is good in its own right so as the other one. Let's be fair to all the encoders with the time and effort they put. Thank you so much.

@VizardX
His version isn't sharp and looks like shit. Quit acting like you're being objective when you're really not.
alt text
Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. Upscaled dogshit with watery lines. I could make a watercolor painting that doesn't look this watery. If you think this actually looks sharp and easy to watch you legit need fucking glasses. It's OBJECTIVELY (there's that word again that you don't know the meaning of) not sharp. Being easier to watch is SUBJECTIVE. It is YOUR opinion. The end.