Nyaa archive 1007238
[SCY] Attack on Titan (BD 1080p Hi10 FLAC) [Dual-Audio]
Saved on 2018-05-27 20:20:20. This copy includes the description and comments available at capture.
Description
- 1080p -
Audio Track 1 (Default): English 5.1 FLAC
Audio Track 2: Japanese 2.0 FLAC
Audio Track 3: English Commentary 2.0 FLAC*
*Applies to episodes 3, 13, 14 and 25.
Subtitle Track 1 (Default): English Signs & Songs (.ASS)
Subtitle Track 2: English Dialogue [Baal modified] (.ASS)
Dual-audio remux featuring Winter's 1080p encodes and my own modification of Baal's subtitles (which uses Evetaku as a base). I resampled the scripts to 1080p, restyled the dialogue and slightly adjusted all of the typesetting. One sign was redone entirely. English audio was sourced from the USBD, synchronized and encoded at 24bit. To my knowledge (and in my opinion), Winter's 1080p encodes are currently the best available and look closest to the BDMV. If you feel like the size isn't worth it, you are better off downloading Kametsu's 1080p or Baal's 720p release instead.
Enjoy!
Comments 14
Looks like a great archive-quality version. Thank you!
Which one is Baal's and Kametsu uploads?
@arkhamtheknight
Kametsu: https://nyaa.si/view/878181 (1080p 41GB)
Baal: https://nyaa.si/view/610830 (720p 23GB)
Thanks
cleo is better
@unknown200
cleo is just a re-encode for smaller size. Can't be "better" than the encode it was encoded from.
How does this compare to FFF https://nyaa.si/view/760323 video quality-wise? I compared both first eps but I noticed little to no differences, is it just me?
Seems that the main difference is that this is encoded in level 4.1 (4refFrames), while FFF is 5.1(16refFrame)
@ThePi7on
Winter’s encode is the best source available. FFF unfortunately used rather strong denoising and debanding which resulted in significant detail loss in many scenes with low lighting or action.
If FFF’s encode was in fact superior, I wouldn’t have used Winter’s encode for my release.
@Scyrous oh I see. Since I didn't really notice difference within the first ep, can you point me to a scene where you noticed detail loss?
No pressure, just reply when/if you have some spare time.
I'm asking just to see that with my eyes, since I'm still learning about encoding.
@ThePi70n
No problem. It takes a bit of pratice for sure. And admittedly, ep01 doesn't have that much action or troublesome scenes compared to some of the other episodes (e.g. episode 21).
Anyway, for ep01 you could take a look at these areas: second half of the prologue, most of the OP, 15:45 (Mikasa running), second half of part B. The BDMV source has a lot of nasty banding and some noise which makes it tricky to encode.
If you didn't notice a difference, I am not sure this release is worth downloading for you. I only made it because I wasn't quite satisfied with the other releases out there and found the detail loss / artifacting too distracting. As mentioned in the description, if you want something smaller (but with great English audio quality and subtitles) , I recommend downloading Kametsu's or Baal's release.
@Scyrous
Yes now that I know where to watch I can see the difference, thank you!
@Scyrous
What software do you consider the best or is the one you would use for ripping blu-rays?
@Raamsa123
I use DVDFab personally. AnyDVD is pretty good too.
@Scyrous
Ahh great. Thanks for the advice.